Does stress affect men more than women?
©FrameAngel / Adobe Stock
Does stress affect men more than women?
Stress is more likely to cause depression in men than in women. Why?
Cross-national and cross-cultural studies have indicated that the prevalence of depression among women is higher at any given time than among men. This pattern does not seem to have many exceptions.
Why is that? Biological differences between men and women, like hormones, explain part of it. These are examples of sex differences. But social factors between men and women (gender differences) may play a bigger role. For instance, in general, women experience more stress than men, and research has shown that social stress is the main cause of depression.
Why are more women depressed than men?
Researchers have defined stress as any major changes to the status quo (existing balance) that may cause mental or emotional strain or tension. These stressful life events can include marriage, divorce, separation, marital reconciliation, personal injury or illness, dismissal from work, or retirement.
Men are more likely to have depressive episodes following work difficulties, divorce, and separation. On the other hand, women are more sensitive to conflict, serious illness, or death happening in their close social network. In fact, research suggests that most of the stressful events that cause depression among women are related to their close social networks, such as romantic and marital relationships, child-rearing, and parenting.
Research suggests that compared to men, women tend to ruminate (the technical term for “overthinking”) more about stressors and have negative thoughts that cause depression. And at least one study suggests that this explains the gender difference in the prevalence of depression. Rumination can make stress worse, and unfortunately, it is more common among women.
These findings suggest that psychosocial causes of depression may be at least partially gender-specific. These disparities are rooted in different life conditions – social inequalities – that men and women experience. And, in general, women tend to experience greater social inequality and social stress, and therefore depression, than men.
The gender gap in depression is the largest in countries with the highest gender inequalities. Gender difference in the burden of depression is highest in the countries where women and men differ more in access to resources and social equity.
And that, oddly, might explain why men might be more susceptible to the depression-inducing effects of stress. They aren’t as used to dealing with it.
Men are more vulnerable to the effects of stress over time.
In new research, my colleague Maryam Moghani Lankarani looked at the question does stress affect men more than women. We found that stressful life events are more likely to predict depression in men than in women.
In fact, men are more susceptible to the depression-inducing effects of each additional stressor over long-term periods.
We looked at data from a nationally representative study that examined how psychological factors affect individuals’ physical and mental health over time.
We studied the effects of stressful life events men and women reported at the beginning of the study to their rates of depression 25 years later. We found that each life stressor’s effect on the risk of clinical depression was 50 percent stronger for men than women.
These findings correspond with a study we published in late 2015 that showed white men might be most vulnerable to the effect of stress on depression, possibly because they have lower exposure to stress compared to any other demographic group.
It’s possible that cumulative exposure to stress may build resilience or habituation to stressors. In other words, people who cope with stress all the time can get used to it.
So the social group exposed to the lowest stressors (living the most privileged life) may, at the same time, be most vulnerable to each additional stressor. They have not learned to cope with stress as effectively as those who experience it more.
This is potentially the cost of living an easier, and therefore, less stressful life.
Men who experience depression may not seek care.
Men may also be vulnerable to the effects of stress because they may perceive depression as a weakness. They may also define emotion and seek help for an emotional problem, such as depression, as a weakness. This is especially the case in developing countries where traditional gender roles are more strongly endorsed.
These beliefs strongly shape men who need mental health care and make men vulnerable when stress and emotional problem happens. All these result in men ignoring depression when it develops and avoiding care when needed, not to look weak.
This also partially explains why more men with depression kill themselves (particularly white men) than women with depression.
Gender influences our risk of depression through various ways. It determines our risk of exposure to adversity. It changes our vulnerability to stress. And it can also determine what resources we’ll be able to access to cope with stress or depression.
Shervin Assari, Research Investigator of Psychiatry, University of Michigan
The Conversation is a network of not-for-profit media outlets that publish news stories written by academics and researchers.